Home Economics The Drums of Conflict Are Rising Louder in South America

The Drums of Conflict Are Rising Louder in South America

The Drums of Conflict Are Rising Louder in South America


As tensions rise within the Essequibo territorial dispute, Brazil sends reinforcements to its northern border, Venezuela holds a referendum on whether or not to annex the area and Guyana mulls internet hosting US army bases.    

Simply over two weeks in the past, I posted a piece flagging the chance that the subsequent geopolitical flash level on this 12 months of residing dangerously may very well be a centuries-old border dispute in an oil-rich nook of South America. That oil-rich nook is Essequibo, a sparsely populated 160,000 square-kilometre chunk of disputed land, comprising primarily rain forest, that makes up roughly two-thirds of Guyana, a former British colony. However the land has additionally been claimed by Venezuela because it received its independence from Spain simply over 200 years in the past. With just a little encouragement from the US, the dispute now threatens to escalate right into a full-blown warfare.

A map of the area:

Guyana: “Essequibo Is We Own” | Three Worlds One Vision

Troop Actions

On Wednesday (Nov 29), the Ministry of Defence of neighbouring Brazil introduced it was sending army reinforcements to its northern border as a precautionary measure. The northern Brazilian state of Roraima, in the midst of the Amazon jungle, shares a border with each Venezuela and Essequibo and Brasilia is anxious that the ratcheting tensions between its two neighbours may descend into violence.

Final week, Brazil’s President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (aka Lula) despatched his senior adviser, Celso Amorim, a former minister of defence and international secretary, to Caracas to fulfill with the President of Venezuela, Nicolás Maduro, to specific the Brazilian authorities’s issues in regards to the danger of warfare breaking out between the 2 nations. That assembly doesn’t seem to have had the specified impact. On Wednesday, Lula posted a message on X reminding that (machine translated):

When a rustic decides to go to warfare, it’s declaring the chapter of dialogue. And I got here into politics by way of dialogue, and I consider that it’s rather more wise and efficient to waste a number of hours at negotiating tables than to go round taking pictures at random, killing harmless girls, youngsters and males.

The Brazilian authorities is especially involved in regards to the attainable fallout from a preferred consultative referendum the Maduro authorities is holding this Sunday on the nation’s rights over Essequibo. The referendum consists of 5 questions, the fifth of which is whether or not residents agree that incorporating Essequibo as a part of Venezuela’s personal territory and granting its “present and future inhabitants” Venezuelan citizenship is a good suggestion.

Guyana’s authorities can also be understandably involved. The Maduro authorities insists that the referendum is solely consultative and non-binding, and it has no intention of annexing the territory. However on the similar time it’s amassing troops near its border with Essequibo, ostensibly to fight unlawful mining actions. Ominously, Venezuela’s Minister of Defence Vladimir Padrino López lately stated the dispute with Guyana “shouldn’t be an armed warfare, for now.”

“Exit and vote (within the referendum). This isn’t an armed warfare, for now, it isn’t an armed warfare,” he stated, including that the members of the Bolivarian Nationwide Armed Forces (FANB) might be “completely on guard” for “any motion that threatens” the nation’s “territorial integrity.”

The federal government of Guyana can also be elevating the stakes. Up till final week it had repeatedly denied allegations from Caracas that it was planning to ask US Southern Command to arrange a ahead working base in Essequibo. However then final Friday the nation’s Vice President Bharrat Jagdeo stated in a press convention:

“We’ve by no means been occupied with army bases, however we have now to guard our nationwide curiosity… We’re going to be working with a variety of nations on larger defence cooperation. We can have from the US Division of Defence subsequent week two visits to Guyana, by two groups. After which a number of different visits within the month of December after which excessive degree illustration from the Division of Defence right here.”

In different phrases, it seems that US Southern Command is about to arrange a brand new ahead working base, or bases, in a territory that’s nonetheless very a lot in dispute. That territory shouldn’t be solely wealthy in oil and gasoline but in addition boasts different mineral deposits, together with Gold and Bauxite, in addition to large fish shares and recent water provides. Additionally of notice is Jagdeo’s point out of “a variety of nations” with which it’s looking for “larger defence nations.” These nations embody Canada, which has mining pursuits throughout Latin America, Brazil and

The US and Guyana already signed an settlement in 2020 to undertake joint army patrols within the Essequibo area, ostensibly for “drug interdiction” and to offer “larger safety” to the South American nation. Southcom has signed related agreements with the governments of Ecuador and Peru in current months (as we have now coated right hereright here and right here) and is seeking to do the identical with Uruguay.

A Centuries-Previous Dispute

The present diplomatic tussle over Essequibo could have been ignited by the invention in 2015 of big deposits of oil off the coast of the disputed area however its roots date again centuries. Readers won’t be shocked to be taught that the preliminary instigator within the dispute was the British Empire, which by the early nineteenth century already managed the areas of Demerara and Berbicea (the cream colored territory within the map above).

Within the chaos that resulted from the overthrow of Spanish rule in South America, the British started to take advantage of weaknesses in post-independence Venezuela, then a part of “Gran Colombia“, to make incursions west of the Essequibo river. The Essequibo territory had de jure belonged to the Spanish crown however there was no efficient de facto management over it. Wherever British troops discovered an influence vacuum, they left behind British settlers. It is usually throughout this time that the British occupy the Malvinas (Falkland Islands).

In 1822, Simon Bolivar ordered his Minister in London, José Rafael Revenga, to current an official grievance to the British authorities, within the following phrases:

“The settlers of Demerara and Berbice have usurped a big portion of land that based on the newest treaties between Spain and Holland belongs to us on this facet of the Essequibo River. (…) stated settlers should place themselves below the jurisdiction and obedience of our legal guidelines or withdraw to their former possessions.”

For sure, that didn’t occur. Over the subsequent few a long time the British progressively expanded their management over Essequibo. Because the century progressed, the UK started to settle within the territories it claimed as its personal, though there have been durations of coexistence that put a short lived break on the British growth. With the declare of 1887, which included populations below historic Spanish and Venezuelan management, the federal government of Venezuela determined to sever diplomatic relations.

Issues got here to a head on the Paris Tribunal of Arbitration, convened in 1899 to settle the dispute, at which Venezuela’s claims have been, satirically, supported by Washington. Sitting on the five-member court docket have been two People, representing Caracas, two Britons, representing, in fact, the pursuits of Her Majesty’s Empire, and a Russian who was purported to be an neutral choose. The latter, Friedrich Martens, was instrumental in tilting the ruling within the British colony’s favour.

The arbitration court docket unanimously agreed to grant the UK 159,000 sq. of territory west of the Essequibo River. A number of political authorities and jurists warned in regards to the excessiveness of the ruling. Venezuela formally complained, although it lastly grudgingly accepted the result and collaborated within the demarcation of the brand new border. The battle remained dormant for many years.

However all that modified in 1949, when one of many 4 North American attorneys who represented Venezuela within the Paris arbitration award of 1899, Severo Mallet-Prevost, had a Memorandum printed posthumously that documented a litany of irregularities within the course of – from exterior stress, the partial angle of the Russian choose, parallel negotiations – which, in Mallet-Prevost’s opinion, vitiated the results of the award.

This revelations allowed Venezuela to renew its territorial declare and problem the results of the arbitration award. After gathering info, it started a marketing campaign to legally reopen its declare. Then, in 1966, the Geneva Settlement was signed 1966 between Venezuela and the UK (Guyana was nonetheless a British colony on the time), below which the events agreed to succeed in a mediated resolution to the Essequibo dispute, recognising Venezuela’s nullification of the 1899 choice.

However Guyana refused to have interaction in direct negotiations, preferring as a substitute to pursue UN-based mechanisms together with by way of the Common Meeting and the Safety Council. In 1987, each nations agreed to thrash out their variations by way of a UN-mediated “Good Workplaces” course of. Through the Hugo Chávez period, integration with the neighbour was prioritised over territorial variations.

To start with, Maduro continued alongside the identical path. In September, 2013, months after Chávez’s demise, he made an official go to to Georgetown and declared that the dispute was a legacy of colonialism. Then, in 2015, a consortium of oil firms led by Exxon Cell found large deposits of oil and gasoline within the disputed waters of Essequibo. And identical to that, the battle was reignited, however this time it’s the US, not the British, that’s stirring the pot.

All Concerning the Oil

For the second, it’s Guyana’s huge untapped power provides which might be of most curiosity to the US authorities and firms, as Southcom Commander Laura Richardson admitted with disarming frankness in a speech to the Atlantic Council again in January:

This area, why this area issues, with all of its wealthy sources and uncommon earth minerals: you’ve bought the Lithium Triangle which is required for know-how at present; 60% of the world’s lithium is within the Lithium Triangle, Argentina, Bolivia, Chile. You simply had the biggest oil reserves, mild candy crude found off of Guyana over a 12 months in the past. You’ve gotten Venezuela’s sources as effectively with oil, copper, gold. China will get 36% of its meals supply from this area. We’ve the Amazon, lungs of the world. We’ve 31% of the world’s recent water on this area too.

Beneath is a clip of the speech in all its glory. It’s, I consider, an ideal illustration of late Main Common Smedley Darlington Butler’s thesis that warfare is a “racket” — “presumably the oldest, simply essentially the most worthwhile, certainly essentially the most vicious.” Like Butler in his day, Common Richardson is nothing greater than a “high-class muscle-man” — or in her case, girl — “for Large Enterprise, for Wall Avenue and for the Bankers”; “a racketeer, a gangster for capitalism.” In contrast to Butler (at the least in his later years), Richardson appears to bask within the function.

If something, warfare is much more of a racket at present than it was again in Butler’s time (early twentieth century), primarily as a result of the enterprise of warfare is a lot bigger. In Guyana, the US stands to profit not solely from having access to beneficial mineral sources at filth low cost costs — the manufacturing sharing settlement the Guyanese authorities signed with the Exxon Mobil consortium was so egregious {that a} former presidential adviser cautioned that the nation was being “recolonised” — and with out having to pay the externalities; it would additionally get to promote Guyana shiploads of US-made weapons and different army tools.

That’s proper: a lot of the cash the Guyanese authorities earns from its paltry oil and gasoline royalties [just 2% in the case of the 016 Stabroek offshore license) will be funnelled into the US military industrial complex, just as happens with all US wars. For example, Guyana’s coast guard just took delivery of a patrol boat built by Metal Shark, a US military contractor that has sold well over a dozen maritime combat vessels to Ukraine since the war began there. As Julian Assange once said about the Afghan war, the goal is “to wash money out of the tax bases of the United States, out of the tax bases of Europe,” through the target country, “and back into the hands of a transnational security elite.”

Exxon’s Revenge

The US government had no interest in Guyana, a small country with a tiny economy and one of the lowest population densities on the planet, in 2015. That, coincidentally, was the same year that a consortium of firms led by Exxon Mobil discovered huge deposits of oil in waters off the coast of Essequibo. For decades Washington had more or less stood on the sidelines of the territorial dispute over Essequibo, calling for a “timely resolution” through bilateral negotiations. But that all changed in 2018, when it began calling for the hugely controversial 1899 arbitration decision* to be upheld.

In the same year, Guyana filed an application before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) asking the Court to reaffirm the 1899 arbitration award that established the boundary between Guyana and Venezuela. In 2020, the ICJ ruled against Venezuela, whose government refuses to acknowledge ICJ jurisdiction on the matter.

As the Washington Post reported in 2017, the discovery of oil in Essequibo was the perfect revenge for Exxon’s then-CEO Rex Tillerson, who Donald Trump would later go on to appoint as his secretary of state:

Rex Tillerson hadn’t been CEO of ExxonMobil very long when the late president Hugo Chavez made foreign oil companies in Venezuela an offer they couldn’t refuse. Give the government a bigger cut, or else.

Most of the companies took the deal. Tillerson refused.

Chavez responded in 2007 by nationalizing ExxonMobil’s considerable assets in the country, which the company valued at $10 billion. The losses were a big blow to Tillerson, who reportedly took the seizure as a personal affront.

Only Tillerson didn’t get mad, at least in public. He got even.

Flash forward to May 2015. Just five days after former military general David Granger was elected president of the South American nation of Guyana, unseating the country’s long-ruling leftist party, ExxonMobil made a big announcement.

In the deep blue waters120 miles off Guyana’s coast, the company scored a major oil discovery: as much as 1.4 billion barrels of high-quality crude. Tillerson told company shareholders the well, Liza-1, was the largest oil find anywhere in the world that year.

For tiny Guyana (population 800,000), the continent’s only English-speaking country and one of its poorest, it was a fortune-changing event, certain to mark a “before and after” in a country long isolated by language and geography.

There was just one problem with this undersea bonanza. Venezuela claimed the waters — and the hydrocarbons beneath them — as its own.

Clearly drilling in the disputed area was potentially a good business decision for ExxonMobil, not some sort of elaborate revenge scheme by its CEO

But revenge had been served. Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, Chavez’s successor, was livid.

“There is a brutal campaign against Venezuela of lies, funded by ExxonMobil … which has great influence at the Pentagon,” Maduro declared, calling the dispute an attempt to corner Venezuela and precipitate “a high-intensity conflict.”

Since then the US has waged a brutal economic war against Venezuela; it has, together with the UK government and Bank of England, confiscated its gold; prevented medical supplies from reaching the country during the COVID-19 pandemic, and even tried to engineer a coup against the Maduro government by appointing Juan Guaidó “interim president”, with farcical consequences. Now holed up in Florida, Guaidó faces a raft of criminal charges back home including treason, usurpation of functions, profit or extraction of money, securities or public goods, money laundering and association to commit a crime.

Yet even as the US is on the verge of establishing another military foothold just across the border from Venezuela (Southcom already has seven or eight official military bases and many more unofficial ones in Colombia, whose Petro government has reestablished commercial and diplomatic ties with Caracas), it is also in the process of lifting sanctions against Venezuelan oil, gas and gold. On Tuesday, Maduro asked Joe Biden to lift all the remaining sanctions and begin a new era of relations “at the highest level” — something the Biden administration is not ready to contemplate until at least after next year’s elections.  

Print Friendly, PDF & Email



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here